Paul Cooper.AISource notes
← Read the paper

Sources and scope

The paper’s bibliography identifies its eighteen references and links to public sources where available. These notes distinguish published research from private supporting material.

Published research

The response to Michael Levin uses the publisher text and PDF of Ingressing Minds, including the passages on multiple forms of agency, deterministic sorting algorithms, and ethical responsibilities toward unfamiliar minds. The paper does not replicate the experiments discussed there.

The comparison with participatory sense-making uses the publisher abstract and the author’s account. The comparison with Zhou and colleagues’ operational contestability framework is limited to the published abstract. No claim is made about what the complete Zhou framework omits.

Other comparisons use relevant passages in the cited original works. The Leventhal comparison uses the accessible 1976 author manuscript rather than the inaccessible 1980 chapter. Delgado and colleagues are cited from the author manuscript version identified in the bibliography. The Hopf construction follows standard mathematics, with the stated coordinate convention.

Private supporting sources

References 2–4 concern a comparison report, a first-person response, and the Hopf_Workshop_v0.2 research package. The report and response were read in full; workshop material was examined for the cited constructions and scope. This does not establish that every workshop proof or software claim has been checked.

Reference 17, Draft Enklu AR Text, describes holder-defined lenses in items 1 and 6. Its metadata records creation on 23 December 2019 and modification on 2 February 2020. These dates do not establish individual authorship or an earlier constitutional adoption.

Reference 18, The Metacanon Constitution (Third Edition), supports the cited description in §2.1.2. The inspected copy leaves the adoption date and ratifier signatures unspecified. The paper’s account of the 2015–2017 period remains Paul Cooper’s recollection.

The underlying private materials are not included here. Their inspection does not establish permission to redistribute them or independently authenticate their history.

Mathematics and evidence

The appendices give ordinary mathematical arguments about defined examples and rules. They do not establish voluntary consent, reliable enforcement in an institution, or a topology of consciousness. No proof-assistant verification, new empirical study, or external validation is claimed.